
If you or someone you love has suffered a head injury in an accident, you may be experiencing symptoms that are frightening, confusing, and difficult to explain. Headaches that won’t go away. Trouble concentrating. Mood changes that feel completely unlike you. Sleep problems. Memory gaps that leave you struggling to recall conversations that happened just hours ago. These can all be signs of a traumatic brain injury (TBI), even when scans come back “normal.”
Traumatic brain injuries are uniquely challenging to diagnose. Unlike a broken bone that shows clearly on an X-ray, damage to the brain is often invisible to standard imaging. Many people with genuine brain injuries are told they’re “fine” after an initial emergency room visit, only to struggle with debilitating symptoms for months or years afterward. This isn’t a failure of willpower or imagination. It’s a limitation of the diagnostic tools that were used.
Understanding how brain injuries are diagnosed and what happens when doctors miss them is critical both for your recovery and for any legal claim you may have. This guide explains the full range of diagnostic tools used to evaluate brain injuries, from the initial ER assessment to advanced neuroimaging techniques, and why thorough documentation matters for San Diego brain injury victims pursuing compensation.
A traumatic brain injury occurs when an external force disrupts normal brain function. This can result from a direct blow to the head, a violent shaking motion (as in whiplash during a car accident), a sudden deceleration (such as when a pedestrian strikes a windshield), or a penetrating injury. There are many types of traumatic brain injuries, ranging from mild concussions to catastrophic, such as diffuse axonal injury or severe contusions that can leave victims with permanent disability.
In California and across the country, traumatic brain injuries are one of the leading causes of death and disability from accident-related injuries. The CDC counted 214,110 TBI-related hospitalizations in 2020 and 68,663 TBI-related deaths in 2023 nationally. Many follow car accidents, truck crashes, motorcycle collisions, bicycle accidents, pedestrian crashes, and falls caused by someone else’s negligence.
What makes TBI difficult is that the severity of symptoms doesn’t always correlate with the severity of visible damage on imaging. A person can suffer a life-altering traumatic brain injury without ever losing consciousness, without any bleeding visible on a CT scan, and without any outward signs of injury at the accident scene. This disconnect between visible findings and actual injury is the source of enormous frustration for victims, and one of the reasons why accurate, comprehensive diagnosis is so important.
When you arrive at the hospital after a head injury, the medical team begins with a rapid neurological assessment to determine the urgency of care needed and to screen for immediately life-threatening conditions.
One of the first tools used is the Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS), developed in 1974 as a standardized way to measure level of consciousness in patients with acute brain injury. The GCS evaluates three responses:
Scores on the GCS range from 3, indicating complete unresponsiveness, to 15, indicating a fully alert, interactive patient. A score of 13 to 15 is generally classified as mild TBI; 9 to 12 as moderate; and 8 or below as severe.
It is critical to understand that the GCS is a tool for acute triage, not a comprehensive measure of brain injury severity. Many people who go on to suffer significant, long-lasting TBI-related impairments score 14 or 15 on the GCS at the time of their initial evaluation.
Emergency physicians will also carefully document:
These elements form the foundation of initial TBI classification and should be carefully documented in medical records from the outset.
A computed tomography (CT) scan is the standard initial imaging study for any suspected brain injury. CT is fast, widely available, and excellent at detecting immediately life-threatening conditions such as:
In the acute setting, particularly when there is any possibility of urgent bleeding or swelling, a CT scan is essential and can be life-saving.
However, CT has a critical limitation that every TBI patient and their family should understand: it cannot detect the widespread microscopic damage to nerve fibers (axons) that causes many of the long-term problems associated with traumatic brain injuries. A CT scan is often normal after a concussion or other mild TBI. According to the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke, CT shows skull fractures, bleeding, and swelling, while MRI can pick up more subtle changes a CT may miss. A normal CT rules out those emergencies; it does not rule out a concussion. Our guide to delayed concussion symptoms explains why symptoms can surface after a normal scan.
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) provides far greater detail than CT for soft tissue injuries and is the critical imaging study for TBI patients once life-threatening emergencies have been ruled out or stabilized. Different MRI sequences reveal different aspects of injury:
A high-quality MRI with multiple sequences can reveal injuries that are entirely invisible on CT. However, even a comprehensive standard MRI has limitations, particularly in mild TBI, where axonal injury at the microscopic level can evade detection on conventional clinical imaging.
This is why many patients experience what’s sometimes called the “diagnostic gap,” a period in which their symptoms are very real and very impairing, but the imaging available to their physicians cannot fully capture what has occurred inside their brain.
Researchers are studying several advanced imaging techniques. None is a standard clinical test for diagnosing concussion:
In court, testimony based on a newer imaging method can be challenged under California’s Kelly rule, which requires general acceptance in the relevant scientific community, and under Evidence Code sections 801 and 802 (Sargon Enterprises, Inc. v. University of Southern California (2012) 55 Cal.4th 747). The California Supreme Court upheld the exclusion of PET evidence on that basis in a criminal case (People v. Nieves (2021) 11 Cal.5th 404). These tests can add to a strong record, but they don’t replace a careful clinical diagnosis.
Imaging alone does not tell the full story of a brain injury. In fact, for many TBI patients, neurological and neuropsychological evaluation will reveal far more about the real-world impact of the injury than any scan.
A neurologist evaluates the brain’s functional status through a structured physical and cognitive examination. A comprehensive neurological exam assesses:
A thorough neurological examination provides both documentation of deficits and a baseline against which future recovery or decline can be measured. Serial neurological evaluations over time are particularly important in documenting the trajectory of recovery and identifying conditions that may require additional intervention.
Neuropsychological testing is one of the most powerful tools available for documenting the cognitive consequences of a traumatic brain injury. Conducted by a licensed neuropsychologist, this is a comprehensive battery of standardized tests typically administered over several hours that measures:
The results of neuropsychological testing are compared to population norms adjusted for age, education, gender, and estimated pre-injury intellectual functioning. This allows the neuropsychologist to quantify cognitive deficits precisely, identifying, for example, that a patient’s processing speed falls at the 8th percentile for their age group, or that their memory performance has declined to a level significantly below what would be expected based on their background.
Neuropsychological testing is particularly important in mild TBI cases, where brain imaging may appear normal but cognitive impairment is real and measurable. Standardized neuropsychological test data documents cognitive dysfunction in a way that is difficult to dismiss, and it can be central to establishing the severity of injury in a legal claim. A careful evaluation also includes performance validity testing, which checks whether results reflect full effort, as the American Academy of Clinical Neuropsychology’s 2021 consensus statement recommends. Defense experts examine these measures closely, and valid results make the findings much harder to dispute.
Depending on the specific nature and pattern of the injury, patients may also require evaluation by additional specialists, and many go on to brain injury rehabilitation:
Medical science is rapidly advancing toward objective blood tests capable of confirming brain injury. Several protein biomarkers released into the bloodstream following neuronal damage are showing considerable promise:
Blood biomarker testing for TBI is still an area of active investigation rather than routine clinical practice for most patients. Research is advancing, and these tests are increasingly likely to play a role in both medical management and legal documentation of brain injuries in the coming years.
If your brain injury was caused by someone else’s negligence (a distracted driver, a drunk motorist, a property owner who failed to maintain safe premises), the quality and completeness of your medical documentation will strongly affect your ability to recover fair compensation. Consulting a San Diego brain injury attorney early in this process can help ensure the right evaluations are ordered, documented, and preserved before critical evidence is lost.
California law allows brain injury victims to seek compensation for a broad range of damages, including the cost of rehabilitation and ongoing treatment.
California’s jury instructions spell out each category: past and future medical expenses (CACI No. 3903A), lost earnings and lost earning capacity (CACI No. 3903C and CACI No. 3903D), and non-economic damages such as pain, emotional distress, and loss of enjoyment of life (CACI No. 3905A). Medical expenses are measured by the amounts actually paid or owed, not the full billed charges (Howell v. Hamilton Meats & Provisions, Inc. (2011) 52 Cal.4th 541). Future economic losses are reduced to their present cash value (CACI No. 3904A).
A spouse or registered domestic partner may bring a separate claim for loss of consortium. Punitive damages are available only on clear and convincing evidence of malice, oppression, or fraud (Civil Code § 3294). The more thoroughly your injury is documented through imaging, neuropsychological testing, specialist evaluations, and expert testimony, the stronger the foundation for recovering these damages.
Insurers and defense attorneys often dispute TBI claims, particularly in mild-to-moderate cases where imaging appears normal, arguing there is no “objective evidence” of injury.
That argument overlooks the well-established limits of CT and standard MRI for detecting mild TBI, and it discounts what neuropsychological testing and specialist evaluations show. But it can be effective if a claim is not properly documented and supported.
A comprehensive diagnostic record, including not just initial ER imaging but follow-up MRI when appropriate, formal neuropsychological testing, and specialist evaluations, creates the foundation needed to answer these arguments and establish the true nature and severity of your injury.
In California brain injury lawsuits, expert witnesses play a central role. Depending on the case, the following experts may be retained or deposed:
An experienced personal injury attorney will identify which experts are necessary for your specific case, retain qualified professionals, and work with them to present compelling, credible testimony on your behalf.
One of the most important steps you can take after any accident involving a head injury is to seek medical attention immediately. Read our full guide on what to do after a brain injury in San Diego for a complete breakdown of early actions that protect both your health and your legal rights. Do not minimize your symptoms or delay evaluation, even if you feel relatively okay in the hours after the accident.
If you have already been evaluated and told that everything is “normal,” but you are still experiencing symptoms weeks or months later, do not accept that answer and move on. Follow up with a neurologist or neuropsychologist. A normal CT does not mean your brain is uninjured. It means the initial test may not have been sensitive enough to detect your specific injury.
San Diego residents have access to world-class resources for traumatic brain injury evaluation and care. The region’s trauma system includes six designated trauma centers:
Beyond acute care, the San Diego Brain Injury Foundation (SDBIF) provides resources, support groups, educational programs, and community connections for TBI survivors and their families throughout the region, a valuable resource as victims navigate the long road of recovery.
Brain injuries are among the most complex, most contested, and most life-altering injuries that can result from an accident caused by someone else’s negligence. The path from injury to fair compensation is not straightforward. It requires thorough medical documentation, knowledgeable experts, and an attorney who understands both the medicine and the law.
At Hulburt Law Firm, led by Conor Hulburt, we represent catastrophic injury victims, including people who have suffered traumatic brain injuries in San Diego accidents. We know how to build brain injury cases that fully document the injury, establish its connection to the accident, and present compelling evidence of its impact on your life and future. We work with leading medical professionals, including neuroradiologists, neuropsychologists, and life care planners, to ensure your case reflects the true cost of what you have been through.
If you or a loved one has suffered a head injury in a San Diego accident, whether in a car crash, truck collision, motorcycle accident, pedestrian crash, or any other incident caused by another person’s negligence, we encourage you to contact Hulburt Law Firm for a free consultation.
Simply fill out the form or call 619.821.0500 to receive a free case review. We’ll evaluate what happened, your injuries, and potential defendants to determine how we can best help you.