
Most catastrophic equipment-failure cases in California trace back to third-party defendants the workers’ compensation system cannot reach: the manufacturer that built the defective tool, the rental company that put it on your jobsite, the maintenance contractor that signed off on a machine it never properly inspected, or the general contractor that controlled which equipment was used and how.
Hulburt Law Firm handles the third-party side of California construction equipment cases. This article walks through four categories of potential defendants and the evidence that must be preserved in the first 30 days, before the equipment is repaired, scrapped, or rented out to the next project.
Workers’ compensation in California is a no-fault system that pays for medical care and a fixed percentage of lost wages. It does not pay for pain and suffering, the full economic loss when a catastrophic injury ends a career, or loss of consortium to the worker’s family. Disability ratings can also undervalue serious injuries, including crush injuries, amputations, and brain damage.
California Labor Code §3852 preserves an injured worker’s right to sue a party other than the employer for the full measure of damages. That third-party claim runs alongside the workers’ compensation claim and can recover damages workers’ compensation does not pay, including pain and suffering and full lost earnings.
Strict product liability is one of the most powerful claims available in an equipment-failure case. Under the California Supreme Court’s foundational opinion in Greenman v. Yuba Power Products, Inc. (1963) 59 Cal.2d 57, a manufacturer is strictly liable when its product is sold in a defective condition that causes injury to the user, even without proof of negligence.
Barker v. Lull Engineering Co. (1978) 20 Cal.3d 413 established two ways to prove a design defect: the consumer expectations test and the risk-benefit test. Soule v. General Motors Corp. (1994) 8 Cal.4th 548 limited the consumer expectations test to products whose performance ordinary users can judge, leaving most complex construction equipment to the risk-benefit test.
Three theories typically arise in an equipment case:
Potential defendants include not only the manufacturer of the finished product but also others in the chain of distribution: a component-part manufacturer if a subassembly caused the injury, the distributor, the retailer, and any successor entity.
When equipment was built into the property, such as a permanent hoist or lift, separate construction deadlines can apply to claims against the companies that designed or installed it. California’s ten-year limit for hidden construction defects (Code of Civil Procedure §337.15) does not apply to personal injury or wrongful death claims. A company also does not receive the benefit of these construction deadlines simply because it manufactured equipment that was later installed.
A company in the business of renting equipment can be held strictly liable for renting out a defective machine, just as a seller can (Price v. Shell Oil Co. (1970) 2 Cal.3d 245).
Rental companies may also be independently liable for negligence when they fail to perform required pre-rental inspections, return equipment to the fleet after an obviously inadequate repair, or rent out a unit they knew or should have known was subject to a manufacturer recall.
The rental company matters when the equipment was rented. The rental contract may also contain an indemnity clause that shifts responsibility between the rental company and the contractor renting the unit, which affects who ultimately pays. When the manufacturer is judgment-proof, foreign, or out of business, the rental company is often the most solvent defendant in the case.
The rental company’s maintenance records, inspection logs, and documentation of the equipment’s condition upon return are discoverable and often provide central evidence.
Many large fleets and most permanent jobsite equipment are serviced under contract by a third-party maintenance company. When that company performs negligent service (missing a recalled component, overlooking a visible crack, or signing off on a safety device it never tested), it can be independently liable for the resulting injury under negligence principles.
The maintenance contract is usually the first document subpoenaed; the work-order history is the second.
Cal/OSHA requires machinery and equipment to be inspected and maintained as the manufacturer recommends and kept in safe operating condition (8 CCR §3328). Specific rules also require start-of-shift checks for forklifts (§3650) and haulage vehicles on construction sites (8 CCR §1593).
When the maintenance contractor was responsible for that work and its records show departures from the manufacturer’s specifications, those records become central evidence of negligence.
The default rule under Privette v. Superior Court (1993) 5 Cal.4th 689 is that a general contractor is presumptively not liable to a subcontractor’s employees. The general contractor is presumed to have delegated responsibility for safety to the subcontractor. California recognizes two important exceptions that often arise in equipment cases.
The first is retained control. Under Hooker v. Department of Transportation (2002) 27 Cal.4th 198, a general contractor can be liable when it retains control over part of the work and exercises that control in a way that affirmatively contributes to the injury. Examples include directing how a specific piece of equipment is used or restricting access to alternative equipment. Supplying defective equipment and inducing its use can also qualify (McKown v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. (2002) 27 Cal.4th 219).
Sandoval v. Qualcomm Inc. (2021) 12 Cal.5th 256 tightened the test: the general contractor must have retained authority over how the contracted work was performed, actually exercised that authority, and contributed to the injury in a way that goes beyond failing to prevent the subcontractor’s own negligence. A general right to stop unsafe work or control the site is not enough.
The second is concealed hazards. Under Kinsman v. Unocal Corp. (2005) 37 Cal.4th 659, a landowner that hires a contractor can be liable for failing to warn of a preexisting hazard it knew or should have known about, when the contractor did not know of the hazard and could not reasonably have discovered it.
Facts that may support these exceptions in equipment cases include a general contractor that:
Knowing about a defect, without more, is usually not enough; the question is what the general contractor actually did.
Our guide to the Privette doctrine and its exceptions covers these rules in more depth. Our guide to third-party liability in construction accidents discusses other parties who may share responsibility.
California Evidence Code §669 establishes the doctrine of negligence per se: when a defendant violates a statute or safety order designed to protect the class of people injured, and the violation causes the injury, the defendant is presumed negligent.
Labor Code §6304.5 applies that rule to Cal/OSHA safety orders. In Elsner v. Uveges (2004) 34 Cal.4th 915, the California Supreme Court confirmed that Cal/OSHA provisions can establish the standard of care in negligence cases against third parties, not just employers.
The usual limits still apply: the safety order must govern the defendant’s conduct, and the injury must be the kind the order was written to prevent. A safety order does not create liability by itself; the defendant must still owe the injured worker a duty.
The equipment-specific standards that arise most often in San Diego construction cases include:
California operates its own workplace safety program, so Cal/OSHA safety orders usually govern California jobsites. When the requirements above are met, a violation can support a negligence per se instruction at trial under Labor Code §6304.5 and Evidence Code §669.
The Cal/OSHA citation itself generally cannot be used as evidence against anyone other than the injured worker’s employer, so the violation must be proved through the underlying facts. Our guide to the broader Cal/OSHA framework covers the safety orders that arise most often.
One of the most important facts to investigate in any equipment-failure case is whether the unit was already subject to a recall, service bulletin, or other manufacturer notice at the time of the accident.
Manufacturers announce recalls through a federal agency when one has jurisdiction, their own dealer networks, or industry trade publications such as ENR.
A rental company that keeps a recalled unit in its fleet may face negligence claims. Cal/OSHA also bars the use of machinery with defective parts that create a hazard (8 CCR §3328(c)). When a known defect is ignored and a worker is hurt, that failure can be strong evidence of negligence.
A recall is not the only pre-accident notice that matters. Original equipment manufacturer (OEM) service bulletins, technical service notices, and field safety notices issued between major recalls can be equally revealing. A discovery request for “all communications from the manufacturer regarding this model” is a standard tool in an equipment case and often produces important evidence.
Construction equipment is heavy, fast, and unforgiving. Equipment failures often cause catastrophic injuries, including:
These injuries can have lasting orthopedic and neurological effects and permanently limit a worker’s ability to earn a living.
Fatal cases give rise to a wrongful death claim under CCP §377.60 alongside a survival action under CCP §377.30. Our article on common construction accident injuries provides a fuller breakdown.
The most important work in an equipment-failure case happens before a lawsuit is filed. The following evidence should be secured within days of the accident.
The equipment itself. Preserving the equipment is the single most important step. A preservation letter, sometimes called a spoliation letter, should go to the employer, general contractor, rental company, and manufacturer within the first week. It should demand that the unit remain in its as-found condition pending inspection by the injured worker’s expert. Without a preservation demand, equipment is routinely repaired, returned to the rental fleet, or scrapped, destroying evidence or making the unit difficult to locate.
Maintenance and inspection records. These include any start-of-shift inspection records required for forklifts by 8 CCR §3650 and haulage vehicles by 8 CCR §1593, the rental company’s service file, OEM service bulletins, manufacturer recall notices, and the written Injury and Illness Prevention Program required by 8 CCR §3203. These records help establish what was known and when.
The Cal/OSHA inspection file. California law requires Cal/OSHA to investigate workplace accidents that cause death, serious injury or illness, or serious exposure, unless the agency determines that an investigation is unnecessary (Labor Code §6313). Once an investigation closes, portions of the file can be requested under the California Public Records Act. Some material, including trade secrets and private medical information, may be withheld, so the records available vary by case. When available, this file can be one of the most useful sources of evidence.
Photographs and video of the scene. Worksites change within days. The equipment’s position, surrounding hazards, weather conditions, and site layout must be documented before conditions change.
Witness statements from co-workers. Construction crews rotate off projects. The operator, foreman, and crew members who saw the failure may be on a different project two weeks later and difficult to reach by the time a case is filed.
Rental and purchase paperwork. Rental agreements, purchase orders, and chain-of-distribution documents identify the entities that handled the unit between the manufacturer and the jobsite.
The two-year statute of limitations under CCP §335.1 applies to most third-party personal injury claims, running from the date of the accident.
The six-month government claim deadline under Government Code §911.2 applies when a defendant is a public entity. That may include a public agency responsible for a public works project, a municipal utility, or the agency that owns the property.
The ten-year statute of repose in CCP §337.15 does not apply to personal injury or wrongful death claims (Martinez v. Traubner (1982) 32 Cal.3d 755). A separate four-year limit in CCP §337.1 can apply to injury claims against those who designed or built an improvement to real property when the defect was obvious on reasonable inspection. Cases involving installed equipment, permanent hoists, and fixed lifts require an early review of the construction timeline.
Workers’ compensation reporting and filing deadlines run independently of third-party deadlines. Filing (or not filing) a workers’ compensation claim does not extend or shorten the third-party statute of limitations. Our resource on the San Diego personal injury statute of limitations explains these deadlines in more detail.
Get medical care immediately, even if the injury seems manageable at the scene. Equipment-failure injuries can involve delayed complications, including internal bleeding from crush injuries, compartment syndrome, and head injuries from falls.
Report the accident to your supervisor in writing the same day and ask for a copy of the incident report. Do not move the equipment if it can safely remain in place. If it must be moved, photograph its position first.
Do not discuss the cause of the accident with anyone other than your treating providers and your own attorney. Do not give a recorded statement to an insurance adjuster or sign anything from the employer, general contractor, or a “benefits coordinator” without independent legal review.
If you can, photograph the equipment, surrounding area, visible damage, and manufacturer’s identification plate or serial number. Get the names and phone numbers of witnesses before they leave the project. If the equipment was rented, ask the foreman which company supplied it.
If you suspect a defect (for example, a safety device did not engage, a guard was missing, or the unit had previously been reported as having problems), include that information in your written incident report.
Hulburt Law Firm represents injured workers and the families of workers killed in third-party construction equipment cases throughout San Diego County.
We do not handle workers’ compensation claims. We handle claims against manufacturers, rental companies, maintenance contractors, and general contractors to pursue damages workers’ compensation cannot cover, including pain and suffering, full lost earnings, and loss of consortium.
We work with mechanical engineering experts, accident reconstructionists, and human factors specialists to examine equipment, reconstruct failures, and identify the design choice, maintenance lapse, or missing warning that caused the injury.
We pay all costs up front. There is no fee unless we recover.
To discuss what happened, call (619) 821-0500 or reach us through our contact page. Initial consultations for equipment-failure and other catastrophic construction accident cases are free. We will explain which safety rules may apply, who the likely third-party defendants are, and what evidence needs to be preserved right away.
Simply fill out the form or call 619.821.0500 to receive a free case review. We’ll evaluate what happened, your injuries, and potential defendants to determine how we can best help you.