Construction Electrocution Injury Claims in San Diego

published
December 24, 2024
Close up of colored power wires.

When a construction worker is electrocuted, shocked, or burned by electricity, the employer is often not the only company that can be held responsible. The utility that owns an overhead line, the owner or hirer that controlled a shutdown, another trade on the project, or the maker or rental company of a defective tool can each be a defendant, depending on who controlled the electrical hazard and what they knew. California Labor Code § 3852 preserves an injured worker’s right to sue those third parties even while receiving workers’ compensation.

Hulburt Law Firm represents seriously injured workers and families in third-party construction accident claims throughout San Diego County.

Types of Electrocution

Electrocution strictly means death caused by electric current, though people use the word for any serious electrical accident. A construction electrical injury usually takes one of four forms, and the form shapes both the medical picture and the investigation:

  • Electrocution: a fatal injury. The family may have a wrongful death claim, and the estate may have a separate survival claim.
  • Electrical shock: current passes through the body. Damage can follow the current’s path through nerves, muscle, blood vessels, and the heart, so a small entry wound can hide serious internal injury.
  • Arc flash: an electrical discharge through the air near energized equipment. It produces intense heat and light, and its main danger is severe burns, even without direct contact.
  • Secondary trauma: a shock or arc throws a worker or causes a fall from a ladder, lift, or roof, adding fractures or a brain injury to the electrical harm.

How Electrical Accidents Happen

Three patterns account for most serious construction electrical cases. Each points the investigation toward different people and records.

Contact With Overhead Power Lines

Cranes, boom lifts, concrete pumps, scaffolding, ladders, rebar, and long materials can bring a worker into contact with an energized overhead line. Two California rules set the distances.

California Penal Code § 385 makes it a misdemeanor to operate, place, or move tools, equipment, or materials within six feet of a high-voltage overhead line (more than 750 volts). It also requires cranes, derricks, drilling rigs, pile drivers, and similar equipment to carry a sign, legible from 12 feet and in the operator’s view, reading “Unlawful to operate this equipment within six feet of high voltage lines.” A missing sign is a fact worth photographing.

Cal/OSHA’s overhead-line rule, 8 CCR § 2946, prohibits requiring or permitting work near energized high-voltage lines until the danger of contact has been effectively guarded against. For boom-type lifting equipment, it requires at least 10 feet of clearance from lines between 600 volts and 50,000 volts, with greater distances for higher voltages. It treats every overhead line as energized until the line’s owner or operator verifies it is not and the line is visibly grounded at the worksite, and it calls for a designated observer when the operator cannot judge clearance by sight.

A Circuit Everyone Thought Was Dead

Another pattern is unexpected energization. A worker opens a panel, cuts into a wall, or services equipment after being told the power is off, and the circuit is still live.

California’s construction rule on electric shock, 8 CCR § 1518, requires the employer, before work begins, to find out by inquiry, observation, or instruments whether any energized circuit, exposed or concealed, is located where the work could bring a person, tool, or machine into contact with it. Where such a circuit exists, it must be marked or signed, and employees must be told where it is, what the hazards are, and what protections to use. Separately, 8 CCR § 3314, the lockout/tagout rule, requires procedures to isolate hazardous energy during covered servicing and repair of machinery and equipment.

The applicable rule depends on what the worker was doing and whether the work was supposed to be done energized or de-energized. The useful questions are factual: who did the power-down, who verified it, and what each company told the crew about which circuits stayed live.

Defective Tools, Grounding, or Temporary Power

Sometimes the current reaches the worker through the equipment itself: damaged insulation on a power tool, a missing ground, an improperly wired generator, damaged temporary lighting, a worn extension cord, or a missing or defective ground-fault circuit interrupter. When the equipment was defective, the case may include a product liability claim. When it was rented, its inspection and maintenance history becomes evidence. Our guide to equipment-related construction accidents covers those claims in more detail.

Who Can Be Responsible

Under Labor Code § 3602, workers’ compensation is generally the only remedy against the employer. The third-party claim depends on finding the other company whose conduct contributed to the electrical hazard. In electrical cases, the useful question for every possible defendant is the same: who controlled the power, and who knew it was live?

The Electric Utility

A utility owes a duty of care to make its lines reasonably safe under the circumstances. In Mata v. Pacific Gas & Electric Co. (2014), a case brought by the family of a tree trimmer electrocuted near a 12,000-volt line, the Court of Appeal held that the Public Utilities Commission’s minimum clearances between trees and power lines are a floor, and that meeting them does not by itself establish that the utility used reasonable care. The court also held that the family’s negligence claim could proceed in superior court rather than being confined to the Public Utilities Commission.

Whether the utility knew about the work is often central. A utility that has been told about construction near its line, or asked to de-energize or cover it, is in a different position from one that had no notice. Records of those requests are among the first things to preserve. In San Diego County, many lines belong to SDG&E, an investor-owned utility rather than a public entity, so the Government Claims Act deadline discussed below does not apply to it. A city-owned or other public utility is different.

The Owner or Hirer That Controlled Shutdown and Switching

Under California’s Privette doctrine, a property owner or company that hires a contractor is generally presumed to have handed responsibility for the contractor’s workers’ safety to that contractor. Two exceptions often arise in electrical cases:

  • Concealed hazard: the owner knew or should have known of a hidden dangerous condition, such as a live circuit the contractor could not reasonably discover, and failed to warn the contractor about it.
  • Retained control: the hirer kept control over part of the work and actually exercised it in a way that affirmatively contributed to the injury. CACI No. 1009B is the jury instruction for this theory.

In Sandoval v. Qualcomm Inc. (2021), the California Supreme Court explained that a hirer actually exercises control when it involves itself in the work so that the contractor is not entirely free to do the work its own way. Controlling the power-down before the contractor starts is not, by itself, enough. The cases below show where that line falls.

The General Contractor and Other Trades on Site

A general contractor is not liable just because a subcontractor’s employee was hurt on its project; the same Privette rules and exceptions apply. A different subcontractor stands on different footing when its own crew created the hazard, for example by energizing a circuit another trade expected to stay dead or by damaging wiring or removing protection. Our guides to third-party liability in construction accidents and the Privette exceptions explain how the chain of hiring affects each company’s duty.

Equipment Manufacturers and Rental Companies

A defective tool, generator, cord, lift, or electrical component can support a claim against its manufacturer and others in the chain of distribution, including a company in the business of renting that equipment. These claims turn on the equipment’s condition, so it should be preserved in its post-accident state before anyone repairs, disassembles, or returns it.

What California Electrocution Cases Show

Published California decisions do not predict the outcome of any one case, but they show which facts courts and juries treat as decisive. Four lessons recur.

A San Diego Arc-Flash Verdict, Reversed: Sandoval v. Qualcomm

Qualcomm hired an electrical engineering contractor to inspect switchgear at its San Diego campus. Qualcomm’s employees performed a partial power-down, but an adjacent circuit stayed live behind a bolted-on protective cover. The contractor’s president, who knew which circuits were live, had the cover removed, and a parts specialist working for the contractor triggered an arc flash. He suffered third-degree burns over about one-third of his body.

A San Diego jury found that Qualcomm negligently exercised retained control. It awarded more than $1 million in medical expenses and $6 million in noneconomic damages, and it assigned 46 percent of the fault to Qualcomm, 45 percent to the contractor, and 9 percent to the worker.

The California Supreme Court reversed and directed judgment for Qualcomm. The live circuits had been disclosed to the contractor, which knew which were energized, and Qualcomm had not directed how the contractor did its inspection.

A claim against the company that controlled the power usually depends on proof that the hazard was hidden from the contractor, or that the hirer actually directed the unsafe step. Evidence of who knew what about the live circuits, and who decided how the work would be done, carries the case.

When the Owner Refused to Shut Off the Lines: Austin v. Riverside Portland Cement

In Austin v. Riverside Portland Cement Co. (1955), contractor employees repairing equipment at a cement plant were burned when a crane boom touched an uninsulated 33,000-volt line during night work, when the line could not be seen. Only the plant owner could ask to have the line de-energized. The contractor’s superintendent had asked before an earlier job, and the owner refused because a shutdown would stop the plant. The California Supreme Court affirmed the verdicts against the owner. The jury found for the utility that owned the line.

In contrast to Sandoval, an owner that alone controls a critical safety measure and refuses it is in a very different position from one that disclosed the hazard and let the contractor decide how to work.

Visible Lines Are Not Always an Obvious Danger: Zuniga v. Cherry Avenue Auction

In Zuniga v. Cherry Avenue Auction, Inc. (2021), a couple setting up a booth at a Fresno swap meet raised a 28-foot metal banner pole into an overhead line; the husband was killed. The jury found the swap meet operators 77.5 percent at fault and assessed $12.25 million in damages, and the Court of Appeal affirmed a judgment of about $9.5 million. The court held the danger was not open and obvious as a matter of law, because seeing a line does not tell a person that it is uninsulated, energized, or carrying a lethal current.

The victims were vendors, not construction workers, but the reasoning answers a common defense argument in power-line cases: that the line was in plain view, so no warning was needed.

When the Utility Is Not at Fault, and When the Worker’s Own Clearance Violation Matters

In Krongos v. Pacific Gas & Electric Co. (1992), a boom truck operator swung the boom into a 12,000-volt line and a worker holding the cable was electrocuted. The Court of Appeal held that PG&E owed a duty of care but did not breach it as a matter of law: the line was nearly 29 feet high, above the 25-foot minimum, it was clearly visible and marked with high-voltage signs, and PG&E had no notice of construction at the site. The same opinion reversed summary judgment for the landowner, so that claim could go forward.

In Ramirez v. Nelson (2008), a tree trimmer was electrocuted when his pole saw contacted a line. The California Supreme Court held that the six-foot rule in Penal Code § 385 did not give his family a presumption of negligence against the homeowners who hired the crew, because the statute protects others from the person operating the equipment, not the operator from his own conduct. The family could still pursue ordinary negligence.

Cal/OSHA Electrical Standards

Cal/OSHA safety rules can be used in a civil case, but a Cal/OSHA citation generally cannot. Labor Code § 6304.5 provides that Cal/OSHA’s decision to issue, or not issue, a citation is not admissible in a personal injury or wrongful death action, except between an employee and the employee’s own employer. The same statute preserves the use of safety standards under Evidence Code § 669.

Under section 669, a violation of a safety regulation can create a presumption of negligence, called negligence per se, when the violation caused the injury, the injury was the kind the rule was meant to prevent, and the injured person was among those the rule protects. CACI No. 418 is the jury instruction. The defendant can rebut the presumption by showing it acted reasonably.

The standards most often at issue in a construction electrical case are § 2946 for overhead lines, § 1518 for locating and marking energized circuits, § 3314 for lockout/tagout, and the High-Voltage Electrical Safety Orders beginning at 8 CCR § 2940. A regulation helps only if it applied to the defendant’s work. The civil case therefore has to prove what the defendant actually did and connect it to the rule, rather than rely on what Cal/OSHA concluded.

Electrical Injuries

The visible burn often understates an electrical injury. Current can damage tissue along its path through the body, and the event can throw a worker or cause a fall. Serious electrical accidents can involve deep burns, nerve damage and lasting nerve pain, muscle injury, compartment syndrome, kidney strain from muscle breakdown (rhabdomyolysis), heart rhythm problems, fractures, a traumatic brain injury from a fall, and psychological injury. Many workers need care from several specialties, and the injury can end a career in physical work. Our burn injury practice handles severe electrical and thermal burns.

Evidence to Preserve

The lawsuit deadline is measured in years; the evidence window is often measured in days. Breakers get reset, temporary wiring comes down, rented equipment goes back, and crews move to other projects. “In a serious construction case, I am less interested in whether Cal/OSHA issued a citation than in the evidence of why the accident happened,” says Conor Hulburt. “Where was the equipment in relation to the line? Who knew the circuit was energized? Who controlled the shutdown? Those facts can be matched against the safety standards and tested by engineers and electricians, and in electrical cases early investigation often decides whether that evidence still exists.”

The Electrical Equipment in Its Original Condition

If a tool, generator, panel, ground-fault device, cord, lift, or crane may have contributed, keep it in its post-accident condition until qualified experts can inspect it. Repairing or taking it apart first can destroy the evidence of how it failed.

The Panel, Circuit, and Electrical Drawings

Photographs should capture breaker positions, panel labels, locks and tags, conductors and connections, temporary power setups, grounding, and where the worker stood in relation to the electrical source. Electrical drawings and panel schedules show what the crew should have expected. For a power-line contact, measure and photograph the boom position, the line location, ground elevation, and the work area.

Power-Down, Switching, and Lockout/Tagout Records

Sandoval turned on who did the power-down and what was disclosed about the circuits left live. The records that answer those questions include:

  • Written energy-control and lockout/tagout procedures and lockout logs
  • Switching orders and energization or de-energization records
  • The approved scope of work and pre-task plans or job hazard analyses
  • Safety meeting records and walk-through notes
  • Records showing who had authority to energize or shut down the system

Notice to the Utility and De-Energization Requests

When an overhead or utility-owned line is involved, preserve every communication about the work: requests to de-energize, cover, or relocate a line, clearance information, site meeting notes, emails, texts, and the names of utility personnel who visited. Krongos and Austin both turned on who had notice and who had the power to shut the line down.

Equipment, Rental, and Warning-Sign Records

For a product or rental claim, preserve the make, model, and serial number, rental agreements, inspection, maintenance, and repair records, prior complaints, recall notices, and service bulletins. For cranes and similar equipment, photograph whether the Penal Code § 385 power-line warning sign was posted in the operator’s view.

Witnesses, Messages, and the Cal/OSHA File

Get the names and personal contact information of witnesses before they leave the project, and preserve texts, photos, video, site cameras, and superintendent communications. A serious injury or death must be reported to Cal/OSHA within hours and usually leads to an inspection. The inspection file can identify witnesses, documents, and measurements to develop in the civil case, even though the citation itself is generally not admissible. Our guide to Cal/OSHA investigations after a construction accident explains the reporting rules and how to request the file.

Deadlines After an Electrical Injury

Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1 generally gives two years to file a personal injury or wrongful death lawsuit. A claim against a public entity, such as a city-owned utility or a public agency that controlled the project, generally must be presented within six months under Government Code § 911.2. Workers’ compensation has its own notice and filing deadlines, which run separately. Our guide to the California personal injury statute of limitations covers exceptions and extensions.

Hulburt Law Firm

Hulburt Law Firm investigates whether someone other than the employer contributed to a construction electrical accident: identifying every company on the project, preserving the equipment and electrical records, obtaining utility communications and contracts, and working with electrical engineers and construction-safety experts. We do not handle the workers’ compensation claim.

If you or someone you love was hurt by electricity on a San Diego construction site, call (619) 821-0500 or message us through our contact form for a free, confidential case review. There is no fee unless we recover compensation for you.

No items found.
No items found.

Request a Free Case Review

Simply fill out the form or call 619.821.0500 to receive a free case review. We’ll evaluate what happened, your injuries, and potential defendants to determine how we can best help you.

Thank you. We received your message and will be in touch shortly.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.