Trial Strategy: Start with the Defendant

published
May 23, 2026
A cinematic image of a single empty wooden chair on a bare dark floor, lit by one dramatic focused beam of light from above, surrounded by deep shadow

A personal injury case is made of two stories: (1) a liability story, and (2) a damages story. The jury needs to find liability before it reaches damages, so the first job in every case is telling the liability story well. But what’s the best way to tell that story? Do you introduce your client and her harm, and then explain what happened? Do you tell it from the perspective of your client? Or do you lead with the conduct of the defendant?

When liability is contested, consider beginning with the defendant’s conduct: what the defendant knew, what reasonable care required, and what the defendant did. That is the structure we use in the cases our San Diego personal injury practice takes to mediation and trial.

Plaintiff v. Defendant First

Consider a hypothetical case. A driver running late for work reaches a downtown intersection as his light turns red and keeps going. A nurse walking home from a night shift is in the crosswalk on a walk signal. His car hits her. Here are two ways to open the same case.

Plaintiff First

“Maria was a 34-year-old ICU nurse. On March 3, she finished a night shift and started walking home. At a downtown intersection, the walk signal came on, and she stepped into the crosswalk. A car ran the red light and hit her. The driver was running late for work.”

Defendant First

“On March 3, the driver was running late for work. At a downtown intersection, his light turned red. He did not stop. In the crosswalk, crossing on a walk signal, was Maria, a 34-year-old ICU nurse walking home from a night shift. His car hit her.”

The facts are the same; the sequence differs. The first version opens with Maria. The second opens with the driver and his choice to run the light, and Maria enters as the person that choice harmed. The research below explains why that order matters.

The Story Model

Jurors are persuaded by a coherent story more than by the raw evidence. People in general make sense of information by fitting it into a story: who did what, why, and what happened as a result. Jurors do the same with trial evidence. They build a narrative that organizes the evidence into a causal sequence of events, motivations, and actions, and that story drives the verdict.

Nancy Pennington and Reid Hastie developed this Story Model of juror decision-making in a series of studies published between 1986 and 1993. In a 1988 experiment, they gave mock jurors the evidence from a real murder trial. Every participant received the same evidence; only the order changed. Each side’s evidence came either in “story order,” arranged as a chronological account, or in “witness order,” the disjointed sequence typical of actual trials.

The order made a large difference. When only the prosecution’s evidence was in story order, 78% of participants voted guilty. When only the defense’s evidence was in story order, 31% did. Participants were also most confident in their verdicts when they heard the evidence in story order. See Pennington & Hastie, Explanation-Based Decision Making: Effects of Memory Structure on Judgment, 14 J. Experimental Psychol.: Learning, Memory & Cognition 521 (1988); Pennington & Hastie, Explaining the Evidence: Tests of the Story Model for Juror Decision Making, 62 J. Personality & Soc. Psychol. 189 (1992).

The application: tell the liability story as a story, in chronological order, beginning with the defendant’s conduct.

The Primacy Effect

Information presented first shapes how people interpret what comes after it. Later information is not simply added to the first. It is read through the frame the first information set.

Solomon Asch demonstrated this effect in his 1946 studies of impression formation. He described a person as “intelligent, industrious, impulsive, critical, stubborn, envious.” Participants rated that person significantly more favorably than someone described with the identical traits in reverse order. The positive traits listed first colored how participants understood the negative traits that followed. In 2019, Jessica Sullivan found the primacy effect again across five experiments with 2,882 participants. See Sullivan, The Primacy Effect in Impression Formation: Some Replications and Extensions, 10 Soc. Psychol. & Personality Sci. 432 (2019).

The application: the first character you introduce sets the frame for the case. Introduce the defendant and his conduct first, so the facts that follow are read in light of what he did.

Attribution Research

People explain outcomes by pointing to the choices of the people involved. In a chain of events, they give the most causal weight to the earlier link. Both tendencies favor a story that begins with the defendant’s choice.

The fundamental attribution error is the tendency to explain the behavior of others by reference to their character and choices rather than their circumstances. Jurors evaluating a crash tend to look for the choice that explains it.

Research on how people react to victims shows why that search should not begin with the plaintiff. In a 1966 experiment, Melvin Lerner and Carolyn Simmons had observers watch an apparently innocent person receive electric shocks. When the observers could not end or compensate the suffering, they tended to devalue the victim. Lerner’s explanation was that people want to believe the world is fair, and blaming the victim protects that belief. See Lerner & Simmons, Observer’s Reaction to the “Innocent Victim”: Compassion or Rejection?, 4 J. Personality & Soc. Psychol. 203 (1966).

Amiram Vinokur and Icek Ajzen documented the “causal primacy” effect in 1982. When one event caused another, people assigned more causal importance to the earlier event in the chain than to the later, immediate one. See Vinokur & Ajzen, Relative Importance of Prior and Immediate Events: A Causal Primacy Effect, 42 J. Personality & Soc. Psychol. 820 (1982).

The application: make the defendant’s choice the first link in the causal chain, and show how each event that followed flowed from it.

Applying Defendant First at Each Stage

The same structure works wherever you tell the story. In the complaint, lead with the defendant’s duty and breach before describing the plaintiff’s injuries. The elements of proving liability already run in that order. In the mediation brief, open with the defendant’s conduct and the rule it broke, then turn to the harm. By the time of mediation, the adjuster has usually handled the claim for some time. The brief is an opportunity to shape or reassess how both the adjuster and the mediator understand the case. Whether the case resolves at mediation or trial, that account can shape how the other side values it.

At trial, the first opportunity can come at the start of jury selection. Under Code of Civil Procedure § 222.5, subdivision (d), a party may request a brief opening statement by counsel for each party, and the trial judge must allow it. That mini-opening comes before oral questioning and gives counsel an early opportunity to frame the case. In jury selection, frame preliminary questions around the defendant’s responsibilities and the safety rules at issue. In opening statement, introduce the defendant and his conduct before the plaintiff. A related question is when counsel may first state the dollar amount sought.

The evidence can follow the same order. In deposition preparation, structure fact development to build the defendant’s story first. At trial, consider calling the defendant early in your case. Evidence Code § 776 lets you call an opposing party and examine the witness as if under cross-examination. In direct examination, sequence testimony so the defendant’s conduct emerges before the plaintiff’s harm. In closing argument, walk back through the defendant’s choices in order before turning to the harm and the verdict form.

Conclusion

Jurors understand a case as a story, and the first information they hear frames what follows. They also give the most causal weight to the first link in a chain of events. Each of those findings points the same direction: begin the liability story with the defendant. Introduce what he knew, the rule he was supposed to follow, and the choice he made. Then introduce your client as the person that choice harmed.

Conor Hulburt is a plaintiff’s trial attorney and founder of Hulburt Law Firm in San Diego, California.

No items found.

Request a Free Case Review

Simply fill out the form or call 619.821.0500 to receive a free case review. We’ll evaluate what happened, your injuries, and potential defendants to determine how we can best help you.

Thank you. We received your message and will be in touch shortly.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.