
When you file a personal injury lawsuit, one of the most important decisions you’ll face is whether to accept a settlement offer or proceed to trial. Each option has advantages and disadvantages, and the right choice depends on your specific situation.
At Hulburt Law Firm, our San Diego personal injury attorneys, led by trial lawyer Conor Hulburt, help clients understand the pros and cons of settlement versus trial and guide them toward the best outcome. This article compares settlements and trials in personal injury cases.
A settlement is an agreement between the plaintiff (injured party) and the defendant (at-fault party) or their insurance company to resolve the case without going to trial. In a settlement:
Settlements resolve cases much faster than trials. Trials can take months or years to complete, while settlements can often be negotiated within weeks or months.
A finalized settlement gives you a known amount of compensation, paid on an agreed schedule, rather than a figure that depends on what a jury decides. (Payment still depends on the defendant or insurer performing, which is why the agreement should spell out payment terms.) With a trial, there’s always the risk that a jury will side with the defendant and you’ll receive nothing, or will award less than the offer you turned down.
Settlement negotiations require less attorney time and preparation than preparing for and conducting a trial. This can result in lower legal costs and higher net recovery for you. Understanding how contingency fees and costs work is important when evaluating either path.
Settlement negotiations happen outside the courtroom, and the parties can agree to keep the settlement amount and terms confidential. (Confidentiality is not automatic; it has to be written into the agreement, and some settlement-related filings remain part of the court record.) With a trial, proceedings and the verdict are public record, and sensitive details of your medical history and personal life may become public knowledge.
Settlement avoids the stress of testifying in court and being cross-examined by the opposing attorney.
While trials carry risks, they also offer the potential for higher compensation than a settlement offer. Juries can award damages beyond what insurance companies are willing to offer in negotiations.
A trial allows you to publicly hold the defendant accountable. It also sends a message that negligent behavior has consequences.
You have the right to have your case heard by a jury of your peers. A jury may be more sympathetic to your situation than an insurance adjuster focused on minimizing payouts. Who ends up on that jury matters, which is why we cover the process in our guide to jury selection in personal injury cases.
Our San Diego personal injury attorneys consider multiple strategic factors when evaluating whether a settlement offer is fair or a trial is worth pursuing:
The headline number on a settlement offer is rarely the number that matters. The useful comparison is what you would actually keep under each path, how long each path takes, and how much risk you are carrying along the way.
Three things come out of any recovery before it reaches you: the attorney fee, case costs, and medical liens. Many contingency fee agreements set a higher percentage if the case goes to trial than if it settles, so a verdict has to clear a higher fee before it beats an offer. Costs advanced during litigation (experts, depositions, exhibits) are typically reimbursed from the recovery as well. Medical providers, health insurers, Medicare, and Medi-Cal may hold liens against the recovery, and the amount they ultimately accept can swing your net by thousands of dollars; our California medical lien negotiation guide explains how those liens are reduced. Ask for a side-by-side estimate of your net recovery under the offer and under a realistic range of verdicts.
A settlement can put money in your hands within weeks of signing. A trial date in San Diego is commonly a year or more after filing, and a verdict can be followed by post-trial motions and an appeal that delay payment further. If you are out of work or facing unpaid medical bills, the value of resolving the case sooner belongs in the comparison.
Trial preparation is expensive. Expert witnesses, deposition transcripts, demonstrative exhibits, and jury fees add up quickly, and these costs rise steeply in the final months before trial. In most contingency arrangements the law firm advances these costs and is reimbursed from the recovery, so a larger cost outlay reduces your net even when the verdict is favorable. If you win, the prevailing party is generally entitled to recover certain costs from the losing side under Code of Civil Procedure section 1032, but the list of recoverable items in section 1033.5 is limited: filing fees, deposition costs, service of process, and court-ordered expert fees are recoverable, while fees for experts your side retained are not, unless a statute such as section 998 (discussed below) shifts them.
A verdict is only worth what can be collected. If the defendant is an individual with a $100,000 auto policy and no significant assets, a $1 million verdict may yield little more than the policy limits, and collecting the rest can mean years of chasing a defendant who cannot pay. Before rejecting a policy-limits offer, your attorney should confirm whether there is additional coverage (an umbrella or excess policy, an employer’s policy, or your own underinsured motorist coverage) or a collectible defendant. When the offer already equals everything that is realistically collectible, trial adds risk without adding recoverable value.
Trial outcomes are uncertain even in strong cases. Liability may be disputed, the jury may assign a percentage of fault to you and reduce the award accordingly, and reasonable jurors can disagree sharply about the value of pain, suffering, and future medical care. Juries can also award far more than an insurer offered. A settlement trades away that upside in exchange for eliminating the downside, and whether the trade makes sense depends on how wide the range is in your case and how much downside you can afford to absorb.
Going to trial means testifying in public about the worst event of your life, being cross-examined, sitting for depositions and defense medical examinations, and living with the case unresolved for another year or more. Some clients find that process empowering; for others it prolongs the harm. Either way, it is a legitimate factor in the decision.
California’s statutory offer-to-compromise procedure, explained in the next section, lets either side put the other at financial risk for refusing a reasonable offer. A well-timed 998 offer from the plaintiff can change the defendant’s math, and a defendant’s 998 offer changes yours.
The decision to accept or reject a settlement offer belongs to you, not your lawyer. Our job is to give you an honest estimate of the range of trial outcomes, the net recovery under each, and the risks, and then to try the case if that is your choice.
Before most personal injury cases reach trial in San Diego Superior Court, the parties are usually expected to attempt mediation, a structured negotiation facilitated by a neutral third party, or to attend a court-ordered settlement conference. The San Diego Superior Court’s civil mediation program allows parties who stipulate to mediation to select from a panel of court-approved mediators, whom the parties compensate directly. Mediation gives both sides an opportunity to evaluate the case realistically and reach a voluntary resolution without the uncertainty of a jury verdict.
During mediation, each side presents their view of the case to a trained mediator, who then works with both parties (often in separate rooms) to find common ground. Mediators do not impose a decision; any settlement reached in mediation is voluntary. Many San Diego personal injury cases settle at mediation, particularly when both sides have realistic expectations about the case’s value.
California Code of Civil Procedure section 998 creates a powerful incentive to settle. Not less than 10 days before trial, either party may serve a written offer to have judgment entered on specified terms. The other side has 30 days (or until trial starts, whichever comes first) to accept in writing; otherwise the offer is deemed withdrawn. What makes a 998 offer different from an ordinary settlement demand is what happens if it is rejected and the case then goes to verdict:
For plaintiffs, this means rejecting a reasonable defense offer carries real financial risk: if the jury awards less than the 998 offer, the plaintiff may owe the defendant’s post-offer costs and, in the court’s discretion, expert fees. For defendants and their insurers, a rejected plaintiff’s offer that the verdict later exceeds can add expert fees and prejudgment interest to an already unfavorable judgment, which is why a well-supported plaintiff’s 998 offer often prompts serious settlement discussions.
In San Diego Superior Court, a personal injury case often takes a year or more from filing to reach trial, and complex cases involving catastrophic injuries or multiple defendants can take longer. Settlement negotiations, by contrast, can resolve a case in weeks or months once medical treatment is complete and the full extent of damages is known. For a stage-by-stage look at what happens between filing and trial, see our guides to the legal process for car accident lawsuits and the legal process for wrongful death claims in San Diego.
Your personal injury attorney plays a critical role in both the settlement and trial process. Our attorneys will:
In California, the general statute of limitations for personal injury claims is two years from the date of injury (Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1). A claim against a city, county, or other public entity usually must be presented within six months (Government Code section 911.2), and that six-month deadline is not extended for minors. Settlement talks do not pause either deadline, and waiting too long can bar your claim entirely.
If you’ve been injured and are facing a decision about settlement versus trial, contact Hulburt Law Firm for a free consultation. Our experienced personal injury attorneys can help you understand your options and make the best decision for your case.
Simply fill out the form or call 619.821.0500 to receive a free case review. We’ll evaluate what happened, your injuries, and potential defendants to determine how we can best help you.